Diana Hagen is facing renewed scrutiny after state leaders in Utah announced an independent review into allegations tied to her conduct during a major redistricting case. Governor Spencer Cox, Senate President J. Stuart Adams, and House Speaker Mike Schultz said the initial handling of the complaint left unresolved questions and warranted further examination.
The allegations stem from a complaint submitted in 2025, which claimed Hagen had inappropriate communications with attorney David Reymann, who was involved in litigation over congressional redistricting. The complaint was filed by attorney Michael Worley, who said he received the information from Hagen’s ex-husband, Tobin Hagen. Worley noted he had no direct knowledge of the claims but felt obligated to report them under professional conduct rules.
The Judicial Conduct Commission conducted a preliminary review, including an interview with Tobin Hagen, but ultimately declined to open a full investigation due to insufficient evidence. Officials indicated that further steps—such as obtaining messages or interviewing additional witnesses—would have required more extensive legal action. Despite that decision, state leaders said an independent review is necessary to ensure transparency and public confidence.
Justice Hagen has denied any misconduct, stating she did not engage in an improper relationship or allow personal matters to influence her judicial duties. She said she voluntarily reported the situation and later recused herself from related proceedings. The case at the center of the controversy, League of Women Voters of Utah v. Utah State Legislature, resulted in a unanimous ruling that reshaped the state’s congressional map. No timeline has been announced for the new investigation.