Minnesotans warned Rep. Tom Emmer more than a decade ago that large-scale Somali resettlement was putting pressure on their communities, but the Minnesota Republican dismissed those concerns at the time and criticized critics as insensitive. That earlier controversy has resurfaced following a viral video by YouTuber Nick Shirley, who documented visits to Somali-run child care centers now accused of defrauding the state, drawing renewed attention to long-running tensions over immigration and assimilation in Minnesota.
[read more]
The renewed focus has also brought back an audio clip from a 2016 episode of This American Life, in which journalist Zoe Chace described a heated July 2015 town hall meeting at Aces Bar in downtown St. Cloud. Residents packed the venue to confront Emmer about immigration, with one man stating that many attendees were there to learn Emmer’s views on assimilation. The man openly objected to Somali resettlement, saying local residents had not been consulted and accusing nonprofit organizations of placing refugees in the city without community input.
During the exchange, residents pressed Emmer on how many more refugees were expected to arrive and expressed frustration over what they viewed as a lack of local control. Census data show Minnesota is home to roughly 107,000 Somalis, most of whom were born in the United States, with Minneapolis alone having approximately 84,000 residents of Somali descent. Those figures have fueled years of debate, which has intensified in recent months due to allegations of widespread fraud involving state-funded programs.
At the 2015 town hall, Emmer pushed back against the criticism, which Chace characterized as a response to what he saw as implicit racism toward Somalis. He argued that Somalis were among the fastest-assimilating immigrant populations, a statement that drew audible disapproval from some attendees. A Somali man in the audience later spoke, saying he felt assimilated and encouraging residents to engage with him directly to address their concerns. Despite this, residents continued pressing Emmer to support a vote or pause on refugee resettlement, citing economic strain on the city.
When a woman asked for what she described as a temporary moratorium to allow the city time to adjust, Emmer challenged her wording and said such action was not possible under the Constitution. Years later, as scrutiny of Somali-run child care centers intensified following Shirley’s video, Emmer responded by criticizing long-standing immigration policies and aligning himself with the Trump administration’s enforcement efforts. He said Americans would no longer tolerate abuse of taxpayer-funded programs and pledged to support federal efforts to hold criminals accountable. Following the renewed attention, FBI Director Kash Patel announced that the bureau would increase the scope of its investigation in Minnesota.[/read]